Read

User menu

Search form

Winner Take All: "99 Homes" and the Foreclosure Crisis that Still Reeks of Injustice

Winner Take All: "99 Homes" and the Foreclosure Crisis that Still Reeks of Injustice
Mon, 10/12/2015 - by Lainey Hashorva

“99 Homes,” which opened last week nationwide, is a refreshing reverse look at the real estate and foreclosure debacle without the sexy Wall Street glitz and gloss. The movie takes place in Florida, one of the states most decimated by foreclosures over the last decade, and peers into the dark and hopeless face of loss that millions of Americans experienced with the housing crisis.

Directed by Ramin Bahrani, the film begins at the heart of things: with a family confronting the eviction from their home of over 30 years. We see the family (Andrew Garfield, Laura Dern) pass through phases of grief, denial, reasoning and rage as the villainous real estate investor Rick Carver (Michael Shannon), accompanied by the local sheriff, forces the removal of the family with all of their belongings into their front yard.

At its core, “99 Homes” doesn't just review the foreclosure epidemic that swept the nation with the economic meltdown of 2007-8, but puts a human face on the crisis like no film that has come before it, showing the reality that millions of Americans experienced who were thrown out of their homes as the Wall Street banks that imploded the economy got bailed out.

We see characters handing over “cash for keys,” agreeing to short sales too quickly, and expeditiously vacating their properties in response to banks' repossession of their homes and sheriffs pounding on their door to evict them. Families are told to take what is important to them immediately and get out. Some are furious, grief stricken and horrified; the most heart-wrenching example in the film is the bewilderment of a senior citizen removed from his home with no place to go and no one to call for help.

The main character, Dennis Nash (Garfield), struggles with his own moral compass when he takes a lucrative job with Carver to deliver to other homeowners the same ruthless action he and his family suffered in their eviction. Nash and Carver illustrate a duality between good and evil, as Nash – who must find a way to survive in an economy where work is hard to come by – gets tempted and seduced by economic gain to do Carver's bidding. For him, it comes down to survival of the fittest.

The film takes a hard look at the “winners” and “losers” of the economic downturn, presenting what much of the mainstream media was too afraid to show about the degree of criminal corruption and greed that drove some to profit wildly from the rigged foreclosure system.

In many ways, however, the film simplifies a very complex issue about the housing crisis: namely, the way that felonious banks, which gambled with the public's money and lost, simply paid off the government to the tune of billions in settlements for harm done – but never actually admitted to nor were held accountable for their crimes. The film's oversimplification of winners and losers is thus a missed opportunity to expose the deeper systemic issues underlying a crisis that continues today to decimate the middle class.

Based on what little we've seen from Hollywood in terms of taking on the banking and foreclosure fraud, “99 Homes” does a good job contrasting the inhumane methods used by those in positions of power – the "winners" who enjoyed bottomless champagne and fine cars for their efforts – and the loss and despair of those whose lives the system wrecked.

But where the movie ends here, it could have instead been a powerful beginning to reveal what was really at the heart of the mortgage and foreclosure crisis: the rigging of the financial and real estate markets, the fraudulent manufacturing of documents for eviction, the scams that fleeced government programs which were designed to help homeowners. These issues are touched on briefly in the film when Nash faces a true soul-searching moment. But the righting of wrongs, and the rectification of the facts – what truly happened in the crisis, and why – doesn't get enough attention.

The lack of prosecutions against criminal bankers and mortgage lenders, the failure to assist homeowners who took the giant hit, the endless title forgeries, the Big Bank bailouts – these subjects may be less sexy onscreen than images of Wall Street players snorting through their winnings. But these are the real themes the American public needs to see highlighted. Because they strike at the heart of what continues to destroy so many homeowners' lives still today: a game where winners take all, and so-called “losers” aren't only robbed of shelter and dignity, but of any sense of hope that justice will be served.

3 WAYS TO SHOW YOUR SUPPORT

ONE-TIME DONATION

Just use the simple form below to make a single direct donation.

DONATE NOW

MONTHLY DONATION

Be a sustaining sponsor. Give a reacurring monthly donation at any level.

GET SOME MERCH!

Now you can wear your support too! From T-Shirts to tote bags.

SHOP TODAY

Sign Up

Article Tabs

This last month has shown America that society will gladly tolerate vigilante violence, provided a vigilante chooses the right target.

President-elect Donald Trump isn’t just appointing incompetent buffoons to his Cabinet, but deeply immoral individuals who are completely lacking in family values.

Biden cared more about the appearance of having an independent DOJ untainted by politics than he did about holding an unrepentant criminal ex-president accountable.

The American people clearly spoke, and the drubbing Democrats received requires looking beyond just issue polls, voting patterns, campaign strategy, or get-out-the-vote tactics.

The recent decisions by two of the most influential national newspapers of record to not publish their endorsements of Vice President Kamala Harris says a lot about how seriously they take Trump’s threats to democracy and his promises of vengeance against his enemies.

This last month has shown America that society will gladly tolerate vigilante violence, provided a vigilante chooses the right target.

If the Democrats’ theme of 2017 was Resistance, the theme for Democrats in 2025 needs to instead be Opposition — and these two GOP senators may be the models to emulate.

President-elect Donald Trump isn’t just appointing incompetent buffoons to his Cabinet, but deeply immoral individuals who are completely lacking in family values.

Biden cared more about the appearance of having an independent DOJ untainted by politics than he did about holding an unrepentant criminal ex-president accountable.

The country has never moved as close to the course it took under Benito Mussolini as it is doing now — and even if Meloni is not a neo-fascist politician, she has put herself in a position to appeal to and broaden fascism's political base.

On the eve of the historic November vote, it seems important to ask: What's wrong with men, how did we get here, and can we change this?

Posted 1 month 3 weeks ago

The recent decisions by two of the most influential national newspapers of record to not publish their endorsements of Vice President Kamala Harris says a lot about how seriously they take Trump’s threats to democracy and his promises of vengeance against his enemies.

Posted 1 month 3 weeks ago

The American people clearly spoke, and the drubbing Democrats received requires looking beyond just issue polls, voting patterns, campaign strategy, or get-out-the-vote tactics.

Posted 1 month 1 week ago

As Trump’s campaign grows increasingly bizarre, his team appears to be more tightly controlling his movements and carefully scripting his public appearances to minimize the negative impact his erratic behavior may have on undecided voters in swing states.

Posted 2 months 22 hours ago

Biden cared more about the appearance of having an independent DOJ untainted by politics than he did about holding an unrepentant criminal ex-president accountable.

Posted 3 weeks 1 day ago

Biden cared more about the appearance of having an independent DOJ untainted by politics than he did about holding an unrepentant criminal ex-president accountable.

The country has never moved as close to the course it took under Benito Mussolini as it is doing now — and even if Meloni is not a neo-fascist politician, she has put herself in a position to appeal to and broaden fascism's political base.