Read

User menu

Search form

Hillary Visits a Seattle High School, and Student Resentments Surface

Hillary Visits a Seattle High School, and Student Resentments Surface
Tue, 4/5/2016 - by Ifrah Abshir

It was a typical Monday at Rainier Beach High School. Classes were quiet as usual at the start of the school week. Most students, including myself, were dragging our feet from class to class, counting down the minutes until 2:50 p.m.

Then, during third period, a classmate of mine shouted from the back of the room, “Hillary Clinton is coming to Rainier Beach tomorrow!” Instantly, the class swarmed to her, asking for her sources. At our school we are very politically aware and have discussions about presidential candidates nearly every week.

The news made us act as if we were two-year-olds force-fed several bottles of energy drinks. After about five minutes of yelling and pushing and begging for more info, we discovered that our classmate had received the news through Twitter. We instantly went to several other teachers asking for validation, but no one could confirm. They were all just as clueless as we were. Eventually a teacher asked the front office, and learned that it was true: Hillary was on her way.

Besides the administration, nobody in our school had been privy to this knowledge until it was too late to act on it. We, as students, should have a right to decide whether our school is used as a stage for a political candidate, especially if a lot of the students and staff do not think that a particular candidate has their best interests at heart.

At Rainier Beach, we share a genuine interest in politics, largely because we have to. Being a school with over 90% students of color and more than 70% on free and reduced lunch, most of the things being said in the political world right now affect us directly.

For instance, Donald Trump has publicly insulted Mexicans, Muslims, immigrants, and those who are less affluent. Essentially, he is insulting nearly all of our student population. He has also proposed several policies infringing on our rights as Americans which he threatens to implement if he becomes president. This incites fear in our hearts and forces us to watch the campaigns while praying that certain personalities do not get elected.

Which is why a lot of our students hold animosity towards Mrs. Clinton.

Ahlaam Ibraahim, a senior, said, “I don’t trust her because of her policies and how she’s always switching up. Something in my gut says she isn’t about what she states she is. It’s like she’s putting on a show for us.”

Another student, Naima Yusuf, said, “I’m still hung over her calling [gangs of kids in urban areas] ‘super predators’ and then saying they needed to be brought to heel. This was and is still super insulting to me.”

Still another student said, “I’m not really cool with her foreign policies and how she supports Israel indefinitely. The conflict in Palestine was a problem caused by western interference and by continuing to support the occupation, we are causing the deaths of hundreds of thousands of Palestinians.”

On the subject of race, another said, “We are in a moment in time right now where the conversations we are having about race and identity are becoming prominent and necessary. I feel like Clinton doesn’t do a good enough job of stepping out of her comfort zone to address those problems. She’s really good at pointing fingers and acknowledging there is a problem, but not describing solutions that are intersectional.”

If so many of our students feel this way about Clinton, how do you expect they felt knowing that she was coming to our school the next day? We felt that using Rainier Beach over other high schools in Seattle was a strategic PR stunt by the Clinton campaign, considering most of our students are young people of color.

Yet despite all of our internal feelings and desire to act upon them, we got the news so late that there was nothing we could do but attend the rally and see what Hillary was about.

The next day, after school was over, we waited for hours to get into our own gym for the rally. We were tired, coming off a full school day, and our spirits were low because we felt like we were being sold for publicity without our consent. To add to that, in line we had offensive comments directed toward us. One woman approached us and said, "Can I take a photo with you guys so I can show people that I'm not afraid of Muslims?"

Another man and woman were snickering behind us, talking mess about our school and neighborhood. In that moment we felt like we did not belong because we were some of the only people of color in that long line, which wrapped three times around in the parking lot and onto the front of the school. Can you imagine feeling like you don’t belong in your own school?

After waiting for roughly three and a half hours, we realized there was a priority line for other people to get in first. So we waited even longer for them to get situated, then we finally made our way in and looked around.

People from Mrs. Clinton's campaign were picking out the few people of color in attendance and asking them to stand in the bleachers behind Hillary so the crowd would look more diverse then it really was. It looked as if most people there had never stepped foot in the south end, let alone Rainier Beach.

In Clinton's speech, given to students and staff, it was not about what she said but rather what she did not say. She didn't mention what she would do for schools like ours. She didn't talk about the school-to-prison pipeline. She didn't talk about high incarceration rates. Rather, she talked about holistic ideals she had for the country.

Exactly as our students feared, Mrs. Clinton had a lot of filler talk, but not the hardcore conversations that are needed. She didn’t even allow for a question and answer session, and the only people that got to talk to her and take pictures were those in the priority line.

This explains why a lot of our students and staff appreciate Bernie so much: Sanders actually talks about things that matter to us. He has those uncomfortable conversations because he knows they're needed. We appreciate Bernie because he knows our political and economic system right now only helps the rich get richer and the poor get poorer; that it only continues to be punitive and inconsiderate. This explains why he won the Washington state caucus on Mar. 26 by a sweeping majority.

You would have assumed that somebody from Hillary’s campaign might have informed her about our school before she chose to attend. They might have informed her about how socially active we are. How we continue to fight to achieve equity across our school district, the city and beyond. And how we aren’t afraid of calling things how we see them.

Maybe then she would have changed her speech to better address our concerns, and possibly even shifted our minds to get our vote.

3 WAYS TO SHOW YOUR SUPPORT

ONE-TIME DONATION

Just use the simple form below to make a single direct donation.

DONATE NOW

MONTHLY DONATION

Be a sustaining sponsor. Give a reacurring monthly donation at any level.

GET SOME MERCH!

Now you can wear your support too! From T-Shirts to tote bags.

SHOP TODAY

Comments

I'm proud of the young people at Rainier Beach High School for taking politics seriously and understanding that Bernie Sanders has them in mind in his plan to make things better for all middle class and the poor and needy citizens. Your gut feelings about other candidates are equal to so many others'. It shows you are thinking about your futures and want to be sure you have someone who has your back. Thank you, students.

BTW, I'm a 70 year old man living in San Diego, California. The news of your reaction to HRC has reached us down here thanks to Occupy.com. My best wishes to you students and to the State of Washington.

As a former teacher, I would have loved having you in my class. You're wise and mature and obviously very intelligent.
And--you are the embodiment of what's is great about America. I'm 68, from San Diego previously and am just so impressed with how you all are making America a better country.

I am sorry that you had to put up with her. The unfortunate fact is that most politicians are like her, and that is politics as usual. I supported for decades till Bernie came along, and realized the same thing that you mention. He's a real person and one of us. We are all trying to get him in. I can't promise that we will succeed, but if we don't succeed now, we will in a few years. This isn't going away. Hang in there. Things are going to get better.

First, deep respect and support to all students who are politically involved, getting engaged and active at a young age is critical for the future of our country. As a (young) student myself, I am so proud of the conversations taking places in high schools and colleges across the country. However, I really have to push back on the shaded accusations thrown at Hillary here (and the similarly vague support of Bernie). For starters, the accusation that Hillary doesn't care about certain issues can be easily questioned by looking at candidate's websites. Take the focus on the "school-to-prison" pipeline. Only one candidate has a policy proposal listed publicly on their website to address this issue: Hillary Clinton. Has Bernie visited this same school and talked about the issue? It does not seem so. Neither has Bernie made this a central part of his campaign. Further to suggest that Clinton does not care about race, class, or poverty is directly in contrast to DECADES of work on these issues - not least being her work ensuring the desegregation of schools in the south (well before I was born). Further, if you look at her campaign, especially in the South, she has been providing critical space for many conversations about race, criminal-justice reform, and equality. I will admit (as I can criticize my favored candidate) that there are some legitimate criticisms here (like her support for Israel), but these do not mean she has not care or compassion. Finally, I really push back on any insinuation that she is just saying whatever it takes to be elected. This is a SMEAR coming from the republicans for the LAST THIRTY YEARS. It is easy to believe it when we are told, but every time I look into what she is supposedly lying about -- it turns out it is the right trying to tear her down. This is a women that has fought for progressive causes (just like Bernie) for her entire life.

My ultimate points - (1) there are some legitimate policy criticisms here (and of Clinton generally) that can be made, but the criticisms should be grounded in the stated policy positions of the candidates, and (2) the notion that Clinton is dishonest arises from a lang and artful smear that buying into only supports conservative politics and policies.

It's referrenced here: https://berniesanders.com/issues/racial-justice/ (search in the page for school). He's also mentioned it on the campaign trail. Here he is calling it out specifically back in October: https://twitter.com/berniesanders/status/658997009534337024

I am mystified how Hillary supporters can overlook the millions of contributions to The Clinton Foundation from Kuwait, Qatar and Oman, Algeria, Saudi Arabia, to name a few. I am a lifelong Dem. This is not a "vast right-wing conspiracy." I got this info from the Washington Post as well as Mother Jones: http://www.motherjones.com/politics/2015/05/hillary-clinton-foundation-state-arms-deals, two liberal publications. This, in addition to the enormous amounts from Wall Street (https://www.opensecrets.org/politicians/contrib.php?cid=N00000019&cycle=Career), surely must convince anyone that Hillary Clinton will work for the 1%. Yes, I would like a woman to be Pres., just the right woman.

I went to that event, with four children in tow.
We waited for 5 hours and managed to make our way to the very front-only a short barrier between us and the stage.
The people in front of us looked like they belonged on Capitol Hill -
(young white people sporting hipster tattoos, man-buns and dangerous-looking piercings, clad in Pepto-Bismol pink Planned Parenthood "Act Now!" T-shirts and sunglasses).
I asked one of them to shift a little to the left to allow a child to see the stage. I got the stinkeye not only from the guy I asked, but from the whole row of Planned Parenthood linebackers.
I KNOW those people weren't from Rainier Beach.
I saw the press cherry-picking brown people to talk to, even though most of the people there were white.
I'm not sorry I went. It was a lesson about how politics work. Or don't.

I would direct the student author of this commentary to listen to the very first speech Hillary Clinton gave as a presidential candidate. It was a full and substantive analysis of the criminal justice system with specific programs of reform.

http://www.c-span.org/video/?325657-1/hillary-clinton-remarks-criminal-justice-reform

No matter what hill SAYS, it's ACTIONS that count. During Bill's administration, human warehousing began. America has more peeps imprisoned than any other developed country. After Bill signed NAFTA into law, we started to hemorrhage jobs, which has only been enhanced since. These were REPUBLICAN actions, no matter the rhetoric and greatly contributed to what we have today.

I forgot to mention that it was Bill Clinton, who in 1999, repealed the Glass-Steagall Act, designed specifically
to prevent another crash, enacted in 1929. when those regulations were wiped out, Wall Street had free rein to do what it wanted, Greed is Good, and crashed the world economy. We're still experiencing aftershocks. Notice, Hillary won't commit to re-enacting G-S, that would have prevented the 2008 disaster. It's actions, not words, that we need to consider.

gud artical

Well-written article with your view of what happened. It is great that students at Rainier Beach are socially active and keeping the political debate honest. If we don't all hold politicians' feet to the fire, you can be sure they won't address the real issues. Maybe this article will resonate with the Hillary campaign (and her supporters).

You have a right to say what you think but Hilary Clinton also has a right to visit your school no matter what you think about it.
Hilary Clinton says and does many of the same things the rest of the politicians do.
The difference is that she is female.
Do not take women's rights for granted. They were and still are hard fought for by many women and men. They can so easily be swept away by complaisance.
Political candidates visit places. It is a good learning experience for you to see them up close so you can understand our government. It is up to you how much you get out of each learning experience. If you want to practice how to protest that is your choice. If you wanted to try to ask the candidate an educated question which requires a concrete well thought out answer you had that chance too.
Hilary Clinton is verbally attacked for being a woman candidate and her reputation is smeared due to her GENDER.
When you hear negative things about Hilary Clinton. Stop. Research whether the male candidate you support does or has said the same thing. Then if it is just her say it is just her. If it is some she does and all of the other candidates voted for or said to I would like you to examine your values.

Lynn wrote, "Hilary Clinton says and does many of the same things the rest of the politicians do." The only person I'm comparing HRC to is Bernie Sanders because I'll never vote for any of the GOP candidates. I suspect many people on this page feel the same way. Therefore, if you're contending that Bernie "says and does many of the same things the rest of the politicians do," I'd like to know what you're talking about.

Bernie Sanders has walked the walk for over 50 years. He has more integrity than all the other candidates, combined. And to think that holding HRC accountable is because she's female is ridiculous at best and anti-feminist at worst. It's like saying anyone who criticizes Bernie is an anti-Semite.

I live in Seattle and have been in the struggle with POC and what the student who wrote this article says is right on.

First off, thank you for your comment. I appreciate that you took the time to read this article and voice your opinion. Thank you:)

However I'll be glad to clarify a few things for you and dismantle some clear assumptions you made about us.
First you assume that because she is a woman we are being too harsh on her, but kind sir I am a woman myself. I know all too well the struggles of being a woman in this time and age so why would I discriminate based on gender ? Why would I discriminate at all considering how I'm treated being a female, Muslim, black and a immigrant. Honestly , I would be the last person to judge based on appearances.

Also when you said that she had a right to be at our school just like we had a right to say what we think and protest. This is a strange correlation to me, but your right. Hillary does have a legal right to come to our school. But we also have a legal right to respectfully ask her not to come, an option that was stripped away from us by not informing the school and staff.

I do agree with you however that it was a good learning experience to see how politics work. And in our defense, we would have asked her questions......If we had got to engage with her. Like I've said in the article we did not have a chance to talk to her or engage with her or ask her questions. The only people who got to do that were the priority line people.

On your last point.... I've researched INTENSLY on nearly all of the presidential candidates and I can tell you with full authority that none of my statements are assumptions. All of the things described above, are accurate. Her comments directed toward a group of black men, 'super Predators' were accurate. Her strong support of Isreal etc... And yes I've looked into Bernie as well. Bernie marched with Martin Luther King Jr, opposed Wall Street, addressed the Panama Papers issue, allowed Black Lives Matter protestors to interrupt him and say what they had to say, addressed immigration reform and much much more.

So when we say we support Bernie, we are not saying that we are support a white male candidate over a woman, we are saying that we are simply voting for what is logical and most representive.

Ifrah, you are correct. You shouldn't vote for Hillary because she is a woman anymore than you would vote for someone else because of religion, race, sex etc..... You should vote for the candidate that you feel will do the best for you, your family, friends and our country. At this time, I would also agree with you about Bernie Sanders, he was fighting for equal rights long before Hillary was and continues to do so today. Keep questioning and keep writing.

Please check the source of her funding--that is what determines where a candidate's loyalties lie. Why do we keep shooting ourselves in the foot? I used to ask that about Republicans, now I am even more mystified as to how Dems do the same thing. Hillary's ACTIONS are Republican, no matter what words she uses. I've been an ardent Dem all my life. But the Dems have shifted so far to the right, it's hard to recognize them. That's why Fox news makes a big deal over Bernie being a "socialist." Bernie is almost right down the line, like Eisenhower and during the Eisenhower years, there was a strong Middle Class, a strong economy and above all, PEACE.

I think it's great that students at Rainier Beach are active and aware. What their youth doesn't allow for is the perspective of time. If Hilary had gone to a school on Queen Anne, then that becomes evidence of how she doesn't care about minorities. She goes to a school predominantly made up of minorities, and so it must be a stunt. It also is not unusual for presidential candidates to not give advance notice of appearances. That is a security issue. People sometimes try to kill candidates. Perhaps that fact alone says something about there being at least a little virtue in wanting to put oneself out there in harms way for the honor to be voted president. And with respect, to suggest that Clinton does not have an awareness or compassion for minority issues ignores decades of work and well documented efforts. Bill was pretty good on these types of issues as well. And then there's simply the whole matter of viewing her through the prism of Donald Trump or Ted Cruz. Perspective. Political campaigns are exactly that. Political. She has to be calculating to get maximum effectiveness in the most efficient way possible. In that process, which granted is inherently disingenuous at times, people will take their shots at the candidates and criticize them for not being more this or that. Look past the flaws of political campaigns and positioning and look at the work that has defined their career to see who they truly are. Stay involved!

I am so excited by this column and by the enlightenment I see growing in the youth of our society! Keep speaking... don't let those with tunnel vision effect your big picture perspective. People need to hear your voice. It is time for a paradigm shift!!

Thank you, students - you do America proud by your involvement, knowledge, critical thinking abilities, and study of the two candidates and their actions through the years. Thoughtful, intelligent writing and comments (even from those who support Clinton) and dialogue. I hope to see many of you run for local and congressional politics, because the only way we can change our history is from the bottom up - no candidate for president can do it without support of Congress - something Barack Obama was denied from day one. Go Rainier High - keep speaking out - many are listening!

Sign Up

Article Tabs

This last month has shown America that society will gladly tolerate vigilante violence, provided a vigilante chooses the right target.

President-elect Donald Trump isn’t just appointing incompetent buffoons to his Cabinet, but deeply immoral individuals who are completely lacking in family values.

Biden cared more about the appearance of having an independent DOJ untainted by politics than he did about holding an unrepentant criminal ex-president accountable.

The American people clearly spoke, and the drubbing Democrats received requires looking beyond just issue polls, voting patterns, campaign strategy, or get-out-the-vote tactics.

The recent decisions by two of the most influential national newspapers of record to not publish their endorsements of Vice President Kamala Harris says a lot about how seriously they take Trump’s threats to democracy and his promises of vengeance against his enemies.

This last month has shown America that society will gladly tolerate vigilante violence, provided a vigilante chooses the right target.

If the Democrats’ theme of 2017 was Resistance, the theme for Democrats in 2025 needs to instead be Opposition — and these two GOP senators may be the models to emulate.

President-elect Donald Trump isn’t just appointing incompetent buffoons to his Cabinet, but deeply immoral individuals who are completely lacking in family values.

Biden cared more about the appearance of having an independent DOJ untainted by politics than he did about holding an unrepentant criminal ex-president accountable.

The country has never moved as close to the course it took under Benito Mussolini as it is doing now — and even if Meloni is not a neo-fascist politician, she has put herself in a position to appeal to and broaden fascism's political base.

On the eve of the historic November vote, it seems important to ask: What's wrong with men, how did we get here, and can we change this?

Posted 1 month 3 weeks ago

The recent decisions by two of the most influential national newspapers of record to not publish their endorsements of Vice President Kamala Harris says a lot about how seriously they take Trump’s threats to democracy and his promises of vengeance against his enemies.

Posted 1 month 3 weeks ago

The American people clearly spoke, and the drubbing Democrats received requires looking beyond just issue polls, voting patterns, campaign strategy, or get-out-the-vote tactics.

Posted 1 month 1 week ago

As Trump’s campaign grows increasingly bizarre, his team appears to be more tightly controlling his movements and carefully scripting his public appearances to minimize the negative impact his erratic behavior may have on undecided voters in swing states.

Posted 1 month 4 weeks ago

Biden cared more about the appearance of having an independent DOJ untainted by politics than he did about holding an unrepentant criminal ex-president accountable.

Posted 2 weeks 6 days ago

The country has never moved as close to the course it took under Benito Mussolini as it is doing now — and even if Meloni is not a neo-fascist politician, she has put herself in a position to appeal to and broaden fascism's political base.

Biden cared more about the appearance of having an independent DOJ untainted by politics than he did about holding an unrepentant criminal ex-president accountable.